Lease Options to Renew or Break, IFRS and Landlords' Ledgers
Break Clauses and Lease Options: Know Your Rights, Risks and Responsibilities
In the commercial leasing world, lease clauses usually set out strict obligations: what must or must not be done, and the penalties for failing to comply. But every now and then, a lease offers a window of flexibility, a built-in ‘what if’. These are known as options.
Options might let you break a lease early or extend it beyond the original term. They sound like tools of freedom, but they carry conditions, complexities and, if misunderstood, consequences that could cost your business dearly. In this article, we break down what you need to know about Break Options, Options to Renew and how both impact your strategy, your legal position and your balance sheet.
Renew or Not Renew: That Is the Question
While ‘options to renew’ are more common in other parts of the world, they are relatively rare in England and Wales. Here, commercial tenants often benefit from the 1954 Landlord and Tenant Act, which gives the right to renew leases upon expiry. As a result, most tenants don’t bother negotiating a formal renewal option because statute already has their back.
That said, some leases do include an option to renew. And here’s the catch: unless stated otherwise, these renewals typically repeat the original lease terms in full. So, if your original lease had clauses you didn’t like, they’ll likely roll forward into the next term. That means no room to renegotiate or adapt to a changed business environment.
What’s more, an option to renew can complicate your accounting under IFRS rules. If the option is considered almost certain to be exercised, then the potential renewal term may be added to the existing lease for reporting purposes. That means a 5-year lease with a 5-year renewal option could be treated as a 10-year lease, doubling your apparent lease liability on the balance sheet. Not ideal if you want to keep your financial position looking lean.
The Break Clause: Friend or Foe?
A break clause is an agreed right—either for the tenant, the landlord or both—to terminate a lease before the full term runs its course. For example, a 10-year lease might include a break at year five. These clauses offer flexibility but, again, not without strings.
From an accounting point of view, a break clause might seem like a shortcut to a shorter lease liability. But IFRS doesn’t see it that way unless there is strong evidence the break will be used. That’s because the accounting standard assumes obligations unless they are proven to be conditional in reality, not just in theory. If your business has a track record of exercising break clauses, then perhaps you can justify a shorter assumed lease term. But you’ll need the evidence to support that assumption.
How to Execute a Break Correctly (and Not Get Caught Out)
Executing a break clause is a legal process. It is not as simple as declaring ‘we’re off’. You must comply with all the conditions in the lease, and these can be surprisingly easy to trip over.
You may be required to:
Serve a formal break notice by a specific method
Be fully up to date with all rent and charges
Meet all repairing obligations
Pay the correct sums on the exact due date
Get any of these wrong and the break notice could be invalid. Even a trivial technicality might mean you’re stuck with the lease for its full term, along with all the associated rent and costs.
One common pitfall is not matching the landlord’s ledger. A tenant might believe their account is clear, but if the landlord’s books show an outstanding balance—even just a few pounds for insurance or service charge—the break could be challenged. Tenants should always reconcile their records with those of the landlord or managing agent in advance. In fact, this is one of the key services my team at SmarterEstates offers, and we’ve uncovered millions in misallocated or incorrect charges over the years.
Personal Breaks, Rolling Breaks and Conditional Clauses
Not all break clauses are created equal. Some may be personal, applying only while a specific tenant is in occupation. Assign the lease and the break option might vanish. Others are rolling, allowing the tenant to exit the lease at any time after a certain date, within a defined window.
Break clauses may also be mutual, or one-sided in favour of the landlord. A landlord might need flexibility to reclaim space for redevelopment. In such cases, they may include a break clause just in case. The tenant has little say once that clause is invoked—unless they negotiated protections at the outset.
It’s critical to understand whether a break clause is fixed or floating, personal or general, conditional or unconditional. Any misunderstanding can have real consequences.
Beware the Anniversary Trap
Here’s a technical but vital point: break clauses tied to ‘anniversaries’ can create unintended liabilities.
Let’s say a lease runs from 1 January 2020. A break ‘on the fifth anniversary’ means 1 January 2025—not 31 December 2024. That one extra day means another full period of rent might be due, and if it isn’t paid in full, the break might fail. If the lease demands no arrears, and a final period wasn’t fully paid, the landlord could block the break on a technicality.
This is not rare. It’s common to see a break dated at the start of a rent period without adjusting the payment schedule. Best practice? Overpay the period if needed, just to preserve the break. Better to lose a few pounds in overpayment than remain locked into a lease for another five years due to a procedural slip.
Final Thoughts: Don’t Assume, Always Check
Break clauses and lease options offer strategic flexibility, but they are not freebies. They come with obligations, deadlines and risks. You must read the lease. Understand the terms. Check the landlord’s ledger. Clarify the notice period. Reconcile the accounts. And if in doubt, ask a specialist.
In lease management, the devil really is in the detail. And the more detail you control, the more freedom you’ll gain.
Talk to Gary Marshall at ThatRetailPropertyGuy.com for practical insights, straight-talking advice and strategic support. Explore professional reconciliation and accounts recoverable services through SmarterEstates.
You can find the related podcast episode here. 📚 Read more blogs right here and 🎧 listen to That Retail Property Guy’s podcast episodes for stories, strategies and sector-specific guidance that every retail occupier should know.